Tag Archives: emigration

The Levins and Israel: Emigration to Palestine and Israel

The Association of Jewish Refugees was involved in contextualising Jewish history and documenting the Jewish experience, as evidenced by their correspondence with Ernst in order to clarify the identity of figures in a First World War book written by the Jewish-German Zionist, scholar and physician Dr. Elias Auerbach.

From Ernst’s reply, it is apparent that Auerbach, working in Israel, treated his younger brother Walter Levin when he contracted polio in 1914. He proceeded to record this treatment in one of his autobiographies, likely one entitled ‘From The Fatherland to the Land of the Fathers, the first Jewish doctor in Haifa’, pages of which are shown below. Ernst expresses strong personal distaste for the doctor in question, who apparently refused to allow Ernst’s emigration to Palestine before WWII, due to Anicuta being ‘Arian[sic.] and Catholic’.

Ernst’s reply to query from the Association of Jewish Refugees in Great Britain:

27th July 1971:

“May I use this occasion to answer your question concerning Dr Auerbach’s book: Yes, the Walter Levin he mentions was my youngest brother, who emigrated to the then Turkish Palestine in 1910 to work on the family farm of the brothers Treidel in Kinnereth. He acquired an acute Poliomyelitis there and I collected him in Sues[sic.] … He survived the War Years 1914-1919 paralysed in arms and legs, and committed suicide in 1923; I have loved him dearly. Dr. A. denied that Polio was endemic in Palestine: it was not true”

“I met Dr. A. again in Berlin when I wished to emigrate to Palestine when Hitler was swindled into power. He bluntly refused my application because my young wife was Arian [sic.] and Catholic.; he was extremely nasty and unpleasant to me.”

“Our family farm at Kinnereth is now run my nephew Gabi Treidel, son of my youngest sister Trude Levin who married Oskar Treidel and died in Berlin from a cerebellar abscess.”

*********************************

Letter from Association of Jewish Refugees in Great Britain discussing the memoirs of Dr Elias Auerbach and his mention of Walter Levin. Photocopied pages enclosed

The representative of the Association of Jewish Refugees writing to Ernst stresses the vital importance of documenting Jewish history though family archives, requesting that should he ever want to rid himself of his father’s correspondence, that he should donate them to a Jewish body such as the Leo Baeck Institute London.

 

10th April 1974:

“I enclose a Photostat of the relevant pages. Though I realise that they revive sad memories for you, I could imagine that they will be of interest to you.

You will notice that in the March issue the problem of Richard Strauss and the Nazis was dealt with in an article by Mr. Freyham. We received a letter of protest which will appear in the May issue together with Mr Freyham’s comments.

This brings me to another question … As your late father had personal contacts with Strauss (I think the character of the Kommerz Lenrat in Intermezzo was based on him), and as he was also in touch with other prominent artists, I could imagine that some material (correspondence etc.) still exist. This, of course, belongs to the family. There were, however, cases in which relatives were not aware of the importance and did not keep documents of this kind (early attempts at archiving) … I was just in New York where I again visited the Leo Baeck Institute which has a unique collection of literature and documents pertaining to the history of the German Jews between 1812 and 1933. The institute often receives material from families …”

*************************************

Photocopied pages of Dr Elias Auerbach’s autobiography, mentioning Walter Levin

Auerbach’s account also supports Ernst’s descriptions of his wealthy parents’ lavish lifestyle and connections to prominent artists of the age. Auerbach claims that Willy Levin, Ernst’s father, was an ardent patron of the arts who knew and supported Max Reinhardt in his early career – Reinhardt would go on to become an internationally renowned theatre and film director.

 

“At the beginning of July 1914 in Haifa we were not yet aware that a huge catastrophe was brewing. The country didn’t yet have a newspaper that was kept informed by telegraph … I personally had other things to think about anyway, since in the first few days of July a severely ill young man of 24 years from Berlin, called Walter Levin, was brought to my hospital. He had wanted to settle in Palestine as a farmer, and as preparation was working on the farm of Alfred Treidel at Kinneret. Two days prior he had suddenly been struck with a very high fever. At first the obvious assumption was that it was malaria, but on the second day, paralysis set in on both legs.

He was in an awful condition … the paralysis was spreading and signs could already be seen in his arms too. It was undoubtedly polio. He was at serious risk of death. [Describes medical processes which halted the progression of the paralysis]

… His life was saved, although the paralysis of his legs etc. of course could not be reversed. His case moved me severely. I personally knew this handsome, blooming young man, who appeared that he would stay a cripple. He came from a rich Jewish family in Berlin. His father, Willy Levin, was a well-known businessman who used his wealth as a patron of the arts. He was one of the first, who helped Max Reinhardt in his rise to fame, and was also in general a great admirer of literature and music.

…I immediately let his father know, who did absolutely everything to be well-informed and get the best treatment for his son. Money was not an obstacle. It was clear that he was uncomfortable with his son in the hands of a ‘village doctor’ in some forgotten corner of the world, and urged the transport of his son back to Berlin. I told him that in the present condition this was as good as murder.

… After three weeks I said that he could travel. The father wanted me to personally accompany my patient to Berlin, but it was out of the question that I should leave my practice for six weeks … it was decided that his brother, a young doctor, would pick him up at Port Said.

… Already in Jaffa, we heard reports of a sharp political tension over Europe and the possibility of a European war. But this thought seemed to us so absurd and fantastical that we didn’t take it seriously. We were born in peace and had decades of peace behind us, and now a war was going to break out amongst the great powers? Unthinkable! Apparently Austria had given Serbia an ultimatum which was turned down. But still, one doesn’t set the world on fire because of one political assassination!

… We dropped the patient off with his brother … and I went to Cairo. Everywhere, groups of people stood in the street animatedly discussing the imminent war … when it was clear the war would happen, I knew I had to get out of Egypt immediately. If England entered the war, I would be in danger of being arrested and interned as a German citizen.”

*********************************

Annekathrin visited the Treidels and family in Israel (Haifa), in 1964.

 

Integration

 

Annekathrin Levin was seventeen years old when she moved to Edinburgh with her parents. The bilingual nature of her life is evidenced in correspondence with her parents, often in English to her father Ernst, but also sometimes written in a mixture of both English and German. Whilst Ernst integrated into the Edinburgh medical community, Annekathrin enjoyed much freedom and travelled around the UK and Europe.

The Association for Jewish Refugees (in Britain) was founded in 1941 to help the settling and integration of displaced Jews and still exists today.

Ernst was in regular contact with the Association for Jewish Refugees in regards to the repayment of his war-time Jewish tax compensation and the tracing of family members.

***************************

Letter from Annekathrin’s friend, K. G. Hyder

 

15th February 1937:

“Dear Miss Levin … It was a nice sun-shiny day yesterday, and I not feeling inclined very much in my books, preferred walking outside. I passed my afternoon, up the Arthur seat hills behind Hollyrood [sic.] Palace … I seem to have started my work seriously for my ensuing terminal exam: but at any rate I shall be very much pleased to spare an evening for you at the coming Cosmo Dance on the 19th … I had quite a nice time in the last International gathering and had to pleasure to hear German songs and music. I liked the tunes very though the language was strange to me”

********************************

Annekathrin, like her mother Anicuta, was inclined to art and sketching, with notable examples in her notebooks and sketchbooks.

**********************************

Efforts to contact missing acquaintances and friends

UNRRA, The United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration, was established by the Allies in November 1943. It helped displaced persons and refugees reunite with their friends and family following the chaos of the Second World War, which left much of Europe’s population uprooted and without a secure home.

This public information film, ‘In the Wake of the Armies’, produced in 1944, explains the purpose of UNRRA.

26th July 1946:

From No.1 Tracing Bureau – Austria.

Enquiring after Dr Levin, ‘about 60’, physician, British but former German nationality, ‘possible source of information’ detailed as “he is teaching at the University of Edinburgh”.

Enquirer: Josef Badel in Vienna, an Austrian friend. Message reads “very anxious for news of welfare and whereabouts”.

*****************************

Letter from colleague Norman Dott vouching for Ernst’s legitimacy

Norman Dott, an Edinburgh-based internationally-renowned neurosurgeon, invited Ernst to work with him in his department as early as 1934 – he may have been the reason that the family relocated to Edinburgh specifically, as Ernst worked at the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh. Dott went on to vouch for Ernst throughout the persecution and interment of ‘aliens’ during the Second World War, supporting the family personally, as evidenced by Annekathrin’s interactions with Dott regarding her and Anicuta’s displacement to Glasgow, and ejection from the family home (see ‘Internment’ post). To have such a prominent figure petition for your value to science and society would have been incredibly helpful to Ernst.

 

13th August 1935:

“This is to certify that Dr. Ernst Levin, formerly of the Poliklink, Munich, has been employed by me during the last year in the capacity of assistant in my department of Neurological Surgery at the Royal Infirmary, Edinburgh, and in other associated hospitals which I visit. His duties have included the investigation and recording of neurological patients’ cases and assistance at operations upon them. Dr. Levin is in receipt of a grant from the Academic Assistance Council to enable him to carry on this work. In addition Dr. Levin has undertaken under my direction, research work involving analysis of certain groups of neurosurgical cases and in respect of this work he is in receipt of a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation.

Dr. Levin attended the International Neurological Congress in London with me from 29th July to 3rd August and on 4th August he left London for Germany with my knowledge and consent. My understanding with Dr. Levin is that he is to have six weeks’ holiday and he is due to return to his work in my department in Edinburgh on 16th September.”

************************************

Letter on Ernst’s pleasure at a Burns Night dinner and integration into Scottish culture

In the below letter, Ernst emotionally expresses his gratitude to a friend for inviting their family to a Burns Night supper. He describes Scotland as his ‘adopted home’.

27th January 1955

“It is only today that I find the time and leisure to thank you and your wife once more for having invited us all to the Burns Supper and to your hospitable house.

We have enjoyed it all hughely[sic.]: the traditional food and drink, the good company, the speech, the recitations, the songs and the toasts, not least your own, but most of all the spirit of friendship for the strangers in your midst.

I want you to know that we all consider your invitation to share with you your national celebration a great honour and distinction, signifying to us acceptance in the land of our adoption. This is no small matter for people who have lost their country they loved, and we are deeply grateful for making us feel at home with you.

Scotland has been good to us and we all feel very happy here. This goes for Annekathrin especially and for the Ross family especially who from the very start has treated her as a member of the family with the result that feels to belong. Believe me that we two old birds feel very comforted in that knowledge.”

*******************************

Annekathrin’s career in Occupational Therapy

 

Although she gave up this career path before the age of fifty, Annekathrin Levin pursued the fledgling movement for Occupational Therapy in its early stages. Her father mentions in later letters that working for seven years with physically and mentally disabled children had worn her down, leading to her decision to return to Edinburgh to work as a secretary and translator at ‘Ferranti’s’ and buy a cottage in Colinton in south west Edinburgh. There is much correspondence between Annekathrin and her parents whilst she was working at Birmingham Accident Hospital in their new Occupational Therapy department. She was active around the time that the National Health Service was introduced in the United Kingdom in 1948. In her letters, she records some of the anxiety amidst the medical staff regarding this drastic change and fears for new structuring and administration of hospitals.

 

Ernst’s Old Age

Ernst Levin lived to the ripe old age of 88. Having served in one world war and fled persecution as a result of the second, he was of a generation hit hardest by the chaos of the twentieth century. In later life, Ernst would often reflect on his life and marvel at his good luck in having survived the tumultuous periods. In the letter below, he reflects on the difficulties of emigration with a family mid-career, and the creation of their new life in Edinburgh:

27th October 1964, letter to a friend

“We are getting very old, much older than we had any reason to believe when we left Hitler’s Germany. – It was a stormy passage, with building up a new life in a strange country at the age of 46, interrupted by illness, internment at the beginning of the War, and retirement in 1954. – It was a slow way, but we are resigned to our – blessedly benign – fate, and we feel happy here.”

*****************************

Ernst lived in Edinburgh until his death, often expressing concerning for becoming reliant on his daughter Annekathrin in his old age, particularly after the death of Anicuta from bronchial cancer in November 1965.

Refusal of Pacemaker operation

In 1972, aged 85, Ernst refused the proposal of a pacemaker operation by Dr M.B. Matthews at the Western General Hospital (see below), potentially fearing the difficult recovery in old age.

Annekathrin and Ernst’s relationship wasn’t always easy in his old age:

***************************************

Invitation for Holocaust survivors, 1970:

In 1970, Ernst received a letter from the German Consulate in Berlin inviting him to attend an event in the capital for Berliners persecuted during Hitler’s time in power. Expenses were to be paid, and Annekathrin invited to accompany him.

 

Ernst died in June 1975, ten years after Anicuta, whose death affected him greatly. Annekathrin passed away in 1979. They are buried together.